[请教]沉默的未知，评价还真是两极分化|『动漫主题讨论区』 - 『漫游』酷论坛

[请教]沉默的未知，评价还真是两极分化

gemini22g@2005-01-10 06:29

刚看了一集，自己对这动画还没什么特别想法。
但为了做出是否继续下的判断，就查了些前人的review.

“本片讲述的是2054年至2059年,地球与所谓外星人之间的战争,其结局出乎意料之外.故事深入描画了主人公内心心情的变化.故事探讨了人性的美好与丑恶,是一部比较严肃,沉重的动画.故事与EVA相类似,重于刻画心情,其音乐也非常值得一听。”

中文站里很多都大同小异，像上面的那样，总的来说还算正面吧.

倒是老外们讲话就没那么客气了：
“Review:
Herself the Elf sez: This struck me as a really bad rip-off of Evangelion. Weird, vaguely humanoid/robotic aliens invading, a secret organization trying to use these aliens for their own purposes...along with the stupid design of 'Frank', it was all like a crappy low-budget knockoff of EVA. The plot didn't make much sense, the names were stupid (Morgue?!?), the characters were uninteresting, and the art was awful with really choppy animation. Plus people's noses kept spontaneously disappearing, which was weird to say the least.

What little enjoyment I got out of this piece of crap was when everything in the lab was exploding and the Professor was yelling "FRAAAAANNK!"...I just had a sudden image of that dumb-looking alien-robot thing dressed up in a corset and garter belt singing "I'm just a sweet transvestite..."

Apparently later on in the series there are a whole bunch of pilots and they all fight aliens together (what a novel concept!) with Frank in an organization called 'Funeral' *snicker* but frankly, I'm not interested in seeing any more of this show. A badly drawn, badly animated, badly acted mishmash of other, better shows, Argento Soma should be avoided unless you have a high tolerance for stupidity. Not recommended. ”
画面差，设定差，情节故事差。。估计就配音没找什么茬，日文原版的不说，据说连英文版的也都是些资深CV担当。

不知这里的各位有何感想。

引用

shirleylin@2005-01-10 07:17

其实老外的评价也有很正面的，应该说我看到的review大部分都是相当肯定的。
个人认为很不错的一部动画！支持看下去！！

引用

霸王哆啦@2005-01-10 07:19

没看，大体的瞄了几眼，不管怎么说都不至于到一口一个crap
"dumb-looking alien-robot thing dressed up in a corset and garter belt singing "I'm just a sweet transvestite..."
-__,-这已句，萌！！！

引用

shirleylin@2005-01-10 07:19

画面很优秀，人物设定简约得体，声优更不用说了，我就是从这部开始喜欢桑岛小姐的！

引用

iliiad@2005-01-10 08:23

沉默的未知主要评价还都是正面的，不管中文站还是英文站……而那种随便什么人都能写的review那自然是不可能没有骂的了，不过也是少数就是了……中文论坛上那些所谓“逆天”的评论还少了？

引用

half_angel@2005-01-10 09:12

好像EVA-like的动画总容易招致某些人的反感

引用

birdnowings@2005-01-10 11:13

感觉画面是差了点，个人感觉老外就喜欢一些画面漂亮情节简单的东东